Lately, a number of Western states, together with France, have aided Ukraine’s warfare efforts by means of offering coaching to Ukrainian squaddies on their territory. Alternatively, a case just lately got here to mild the place skilled squaddies ran away as an alternative of returning to the entrance.
The seriousness of the case was once no longer felt from the primary, detailed studies printed within the Hungarian press. In line with a French army supply, they just mentioned
that 50 of the two,200 French-trained squaddies of the a hundred and fifty fifth Mechanized Brigade abandoned within the fall.
The French army professional stated on Monday that the choice of desertions is “very small” in comparison to the choice of Ukrainian squaddies who participated within the coaching, and in addition famous that the French government don’t have jurisdiction to behave in opposition to the deserters in such circumstances, or even the Ukrainian government in France don’t. can take motion in opposition to them.
That is the way it began
The case become a subject matter within the Ukrainian public (via unofficial resources) already in December, and from the perspective of the world press, it necessarily began with a newspaper article on January 1, which was once printed by means of Forbes (by means of the way in which, the English-language social media already gave the impression in the course of December a part of the disclosed knowledge).
Within the article in query, the paper’s creator, David Ax, wrote that Ukraine’s new a hundred and fifty fifth Mechanized Brigade, provided with Leopard 2 tanks, started to crumble after coaching in France however prior to arriving on the entrance, and in consequence Ukraine is now redeploying them to extra skilled gadgets that Pokrovsk is secure.
To avoid wasting the a hundred and fifty fifth Mechanized Brigade, a unit that Ukraine, France, and Poland had spent months and thousands and thousands of bucks coaching and equipping, Ukrainian leaders started sending recent however green subordinate gadgets to depleted however skilled brigades within the Pokrovsk sector.
– stated the creator, in step with whom all this would result in critical issues within the Pokrovsk sector, the place, by means of the way in which, for plenty of months, albeit at a gradual tempo, however the Russian military is advancing (an extra piquancy of the case is that a couple of days previous, on December 27, the Forbes journalist additionally printed a article in regards to the state of affairs in Pokrovsk and that they could arrive quickly to the world gadgets of the a hundred and fifty fifth mechanized brigade – however there was once no point out of the unit’s issues).
1,700 squaddies abandoned and the remainder suffered heavy losses
The January 1st Forbes article was once partially according to knowledge from a Ukrainian journalist, Yuriy Butusov, editor-in-chief of the inside track portal Censor.internet, who ceaselessly stocks his personal details about the entrance, which is later showed.
Butusov had already written in regards to the issues the former 12 months, publishing a marathon Fb put up at the subject on December 31, during which he instructed the “true tale” of the a hundred and fifty fifth Brigade (additionally named after the medieval French queen Anna of Kiev, Anna Yaroslavna). wrote it down. The journalist claimed that “in December, the State Investigation Bureau opened prison court cases in reference to the cases of the advent of the a hundred and fifty fifth “Anna of Kiev” mechanized brigade, which entered the fight close to Pokrovsk.”
The case is below the command of V. Zelenskiy [ez az ukrán elnöki tisztséggel jár együtt – a szerk.]supervised by means of Minister of Protection R. Umerov and O. Sirskyi, Commander-in-Leader of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. One of the crucial leaders answerable for the formation of the brigade died of a middle assault, and the brigade commander was once disregarded straight away after the brigade entered struggle. Sooner than the brigade fired the primary shot, 1,700 squaddies left of their very own accord
– Yuriy Butusov defined the placement, who, in step with his personal admission, performed an intensive investigation into the case himself and got here to the belief {that a} crime may certainly have taken position, however what took place was once “no longer the fault of the warriors and officials – however of the Best Prime Command, the Ministry of Protection and the fault of the Chiefs of Workforce who proceed to waste lives and public cash on new tasks as an alternative of skilled and struggle succesful they might support brigades”, then in step with him they are trying to keep away from being held responsible from below.
The Ukrainian journalist additionally wrote in regards to the desertion of greater than fifty squaddies in France remaining fall, and in step with his declare, after the incident, the French wondered “how significantly the Ukrainians take” this dear coaching mission, after which the Ukrainian government additionally introduced an investigation. .
However the headlessness in point of fact reigned once they have been held answerable for the desertion of greater than fifty squaddies and changed the command of the brigade,
after that, additional desertions happened – on this connection he wrote the quantity 1700 above – after which, because of disorganization, even the troops that had At Pokrovsk they made it to the entrance once you have there with out a drones, no digital air protection (EW) apparatus, and no right kind management.
In line with Butusov, the Ukrainian military made critical errors at many issues, and he believes that Zelenskyi, Umerov, Sirskyi and somewhat a couple of different leaders are in my opinion answerable for them, since a number of dozen of the remainder squaddies of the brigade died within the Pokrovsk sector. In his view, the advent of the brigade may necessarily had been a “PR motion” at the a part of the Ukrainian president at the sidelines of the December assembly with French President Emmanuel Macron.
Volodymyr Zelensky intervenes
A couple of days later, Yuri Butusov already wrote in some other put up that, in step with Censor.internet resources, Zelensky was once additionally just lately knowledgeable in regards to the brigade’s case. In line with his declare, the president was once essentially concerned with his defection from France and Ukraine.
Zelensky emphasised that he would convey the investigation below his private keep an eye on. The Normal Inspectorate of the Ministry of Protection, the Normal Workforce, the Floor Forces Command, the State Intelligence Carrier and the Safety Carrier of Ukraine have been ordered to post professional studies to the top of state at the above-mentioned occasions within the close to long run.
– stated the journalist.
Busutov additionally added that the remainder a part of the brigade was once nonetheless “heroically protecting Pokrovsk”, even supposing their Caesar self-propelled weapons and quite a lot of different struggle apparatus were taken and given to some other brigade. And in a later interview, when requested in regards to the subject, he stated that the brigade’s squaddies had no drones, no digital air protection (EW) apparatus, and no right kind management once they went to the entrance.
I felt like our riding […] would play kid’s play with the lives of squaddies in warfare. […] I believed this could not be actual – two presidents [Macron és Zelenszkij – a szerk.] brigade created by means of is shipped into fight and not using a unmarried drone or EW method. However it was once true
stated the journalist in an interview.
The Ukrainian army management admitted the issue, which is by means of the way in which no longer distinctive, with nice problem
After Butusov’s accounts, a number of Ukrainian army officers said that there have been certainly issues of the a hundred and fifty fifth Brigade (even though they disputed one of the vital knowledge he equipped and stated it can be faulty).
The commander of the Ukrainian flooring forces, Mykhailo Drapatij, admitted on Monday that there are certainly “issues” of their ranks. “After all, I ascertain that there have been issues of the command and the educational procedure,” he admitted to the clicking, despite the fact that he added that those issues “is probably not to the level offered […] have been provide” on the groups, relating to the studies above. Within the intervening time, he emphasised that the choice of desertions is “minimum”, however admitted that the issues noticed within the a hundred and fifty fifth brigade “frequently” happen in different brigades as neatly.
As famous by means of the French Le Soir, the commentary of the bottom commander
it was once a unprecedented admission that desertions have been a rising drawback within the Ukrainian army.
Reviews have turn into in particular commonplace in contemporary months that many Ukrainian troops have left their gadgets with out permission. In line with a information file remaining fall, extra Ukrainian squaddies abandoned within the first ten months of 2024 than within the earlier two years of the invasion blended. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy gave an necessarily evasive solution when requested about this subject in a radio interview in December.
The January sixth article written by means of the Kyiv Put up at the topic, which was once printed below the identify “The Ukrainian military – in any case – admits the “deficiencies” of the a hundred and fifty fifth brigade armed and provided by means of France” may be telling. In it, additionally they drew consideration to the truth that Butusov if truth be told began reporting at the brigade’s issues two months in the past, in November 2024, and different newshounds did the similar, however by means of doing in order that they nearly risked a jail sentence, as a result of they violated the wartime censorship regulation, which “forbids the struggle readiness of particular person gadgets the e-newsletter of related knowledge” – and the military best gave an account of what took place in spite of everything this.
The case become a home political scandal, whilst Ukraine isn’t in a very simple state of affairs anyway
The case was once referred to as a “scandal” in numerous articles within the Ukrainian press. And the AFP information company stated in its personal file that “Kiev was once shaken by means of the studies” and the entire case can also be noticed as a mirrored image of the issues “plaguing the Ukrainian military for the reason that Russian invasion began 3 years in the past”, at a time when “Kiev is a essential political and is in an army place”.
They famous that desertions and military morale are delicate problems in Ukraine, “which faces hard work shortages and controversy over unpopular enlistment techniques.”
As for the particular case of the brigade, Mihajlo Drapatij promised in a commentary on Wednesday that the subject will likely be investigated and the issues corrected. He famous that the case was once made public too quickly, because the professional investigation continues to be ongoing. As he wrote, the issues began even prior to his appointment as land commander in November 2024, however he’s caring for their resolution in any respect ranges relying on him.
Maximum system-level mistakes have been dedicated by means of the Floor Forces Command. The Normal Workforce of the Armed Forces of Ukraine and the Operations Command have just lately analyzed and evaluated all phases of the formation of the a hundred and fifty fifth brigade, and choices on positive problems are already being carried out
he introduced.
We will be able to additionally practice the trends of the warfare in Ukraine minute by means of minute on this article.
(Quilt symbol: Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky on December 19, 2024 in Brussels, Belgium. Picture: Pier Marco Tacca / Getty Pictures)
#Index #Ukraine #rocked #massive #scandal #Volodymyr #Zelenskyi #interfere #in my opinion