Donald Trump Declares “Not Guilty” in Mar-a-Lago Papers Case

After the Storm: Trump Pleads “Not Guilty” in Mar-a-Lago Papers Case

Following the historic day, a sense of uncertainty surrounds the legal proceedings against former US President Donald Trump in the Mar-a-Lago papers case.

The ex-president appeared before a federal judge in Miami on Tuesday accompanied by his lawyer, Todd Blanche, who pled “not guilty” to the 37 charges leveled against Trump. These charges include the alleged commission of seven federal crimes involving withholding classified papers and refusing to return them to the authorities. The entire court appearance lasted a mere five minutes, marking the beginning of what is expected to be a protracted legal process that favors the defense.

As of now, June 27 looms as the only confirmed date on the calendar. On this day, Walt Nauta, Trump’s loyal aide, is set to appear before the judge. If convicted on six counts, including conspiring with Trump to withhold official documents, Nauta faces a potentially lengthy prison sentence. However, a procedural technicality prevented him from entering a plea on Tuesday, despite being arrested and fingerprinted.

The presiding Judge, Jonathan Goodman, refrained from issuing any travel restrictions against Trump. However, the ex-president is prohibited from contacting Nauta or any witnesses involved in the case, unless done so through his legal team. Considering that anything he says could be used against him, Trump must exercise caution regarding his public statements, which began on Tuesday night. After leaving the courthouse and stopping at the historically significant Versailles restaurant, known for its ties to the first Cuban exile in Miami, Trump departed for his Bedminster residence in New Jersey, where he delivered a speech riddled with falsehoods, half-truths, and threats.

The case is now under the supervision of Federal Judge Aileen Cannon, who was appointed during Trump’s presidency. If the Miami grand jury finds the former president guilty, Judge Cannon will determine the sentencing. The next phase of the legal process, known as “discovery,” will commence under her guidance, involving regular court meetings every two months for witness questioning, document gathering, and admission and statement requests.

Following his past relationship with the courts, Trump’s defense strategy is likely to revolve around prolonging the process for as long as possible. The defense’s approach will involve challenging every technical aspect of the case and transforming it into a political spectacle, casting Trump as a victim of the system.

The immediate concern for the tycoon is to assemble his legal team following the resignation of James Trusty and John Rowley, who were handling the Mar-a-Lago papers case. Their resignation, which came the day after the indictment was made public, was accompanied by a message stating, “It has been an honor to have spent the last year defending him, and we believe he will be exonerated.” Subsequently, Trump announced the hiring of attorney Todd Blanche, who uttered the words “not guilty” before the federal judge. The New York Times reported that interviews with potential lawyers for the case began on Monday at Trump’s Doral resort, which boasts a golf course and is located in Miami’s neighboring town.

The Prosecutor’s Strategy

Special counsel Jack Smith, an independent lawyer appointed by the Justice Department to investigate the case, pledged a swift trial after releasing the charge sheet, which will serve as the foundation for the Florida grand jury consisting of citizens.

Noted legal experts Norman Eisen, Andrew Weissmann, and Joyce Vance co-authored an opinion piece in The New York Times titled “How to Condemn Trump,” which advised Smith and his team to strive for simplicity in their case and to shape public opinion. They emphasized that when presenting evidence to a grand jury, it must be easily understood and convincing. The writers expressed confidence in Smith’s ability to present a compelling narrative, portraying Trump as an individual who wrongfully obtained documents not meant for him and then resorted to dishonesty to cover up his misdeeds.

The primary challenge ahead is to prevent the case from becoming entangled in the upcoming presidential campaign, which kicks off early next year. It would be unprecedented for a candidate (polls indicate Trump as the favored candidate for the Republican nomination) to shuttle between campaign rallies and courtrooms.

It is worth noting that the Mar-a-Lago papers case is not the only legal battle the tycoon faces. In April, he was indicted on 34 charges related to an alleged payment made to the porn actress Stormy Daniels to conceal their extramarital affair, an allegation he vehemently denies. Furthermore, there is an ongoing investigation in Fulton County, Atlanta, where Trump is accused of pressuring electoral officials in a state he lost during the 2020 elections. The outcome of this investigation, which could lead to his indictment, is anticipated to be revealed in August.

According to reports, the Atlanta police dispatched agents to Miami a day prior to Trump’s court appearance, as they had previously done in New York, to assess the handling of the former president’s supporters. Around 500 followers congregated near the courthouse to stage a carnival protest, which was not as massive as anticipated by local authorities.

The legal system faces the challenge of coordinating the actions of the three judges involved in Miami, Atlanta, and New York to ensure they do not inadvertently overlap. Additionally, they must resist the urge to prioritize their cases based on personal ambition or urgency.

As of now, the sole confirmed date pertains to the least significant of the three cases, the payment made to Stormy Daniels, scheduled to begin on March 25, 2024.

Follow all the international news on Facebook and Twitter, or subscribe to our weekly newsletter.